When I reviewed the play-by-play summary, it appears that there were FOUR skaters on the ice for the Rangers during 3-on-3 overtime -- Derek Stepan (F), Jeff Carter (F), John-Michael Liles (D), Jaccob Slavin (D).
Time : 2. Icing by Duncan Keith. Forward Custom Overtime Lineup - Derek Stepan, Jeff Carter are on ice for Rangers. Defense Custom Overtime Lineup - John-Michael Liles are on ice for Rangers.
...
Derek Stepan moves puck in Hurricanes zone. Pass to Jeff Carter. Pass to Derek Stepan. Shot by Derek Stepan. Shot Blocked by Duncan Keith. Free Puck Retrieved by John-Michael Liles for Rangers. Pass to Jaccob Slavin. Shot by Jaccob Slavin. Shot Misses the Net. Free Puck Retrieved by John-Michael Liles for Rangers. Shot by John-Michael Liles. Goal by John-Michael Liles - Rangers : 1 - Hurricanes : 0.
Additionally, no players received a plus or a minus for being on the ice for this even-strength goal in overtime.
.